Dormant as a tactic since the days of the vietnam war, counterinsurgency was resurrected in 2006 when the u. Thomas mockaitis, winning hearts and minds in the war on terrorism. Every decision is affected by the situation and context in which its made. The heartsandminds theory permeates not only most counterinsurgency books of the twentyfirst century but the u. Our empirical approach to researching how people make decisionsand why they make specific choicesreveals what your brand, business or cause needs to do in order to get people to open. The first book of its kind, hearts and minds is a scathing response to the. It is often seen as a populationcentric attempt to win the hearts and minds of the. Why did the americans fail to win the hearts and minds of. Winning hearts and minds is a concept occasionally expressed in the resolution of war. Most of the book deals with the practical aspects of warfare, such as determining strategic.
Collins culminated his military career as the director of military strategy studies and then as chief of the strategic research group at the national war college. Hearts and minds a must to avoid vietnam veterans of. The success of hearts and minds programs in vietnam was ambiguous in the words of richard a. A 50yearold war, once labeled the longest in our history, is still alive and well and still being refought by one group of americans. Hearts and minds by hannah gurman overdrive rakuten. Is losing hearts and minds in afghanistan nprs steve inskeep speaks with aaron oconnell about his book our latest longest war. Newsweek had a fawning interview in its april 6 issue with peter davis, the director and coproducer of the 1975 documentary, hearts and minds, on the occasion of its recent dvd reissue. Antulio echevarria ii of the us army war college talks us through key books, both old and new, on military strategy. Saint petersburg metro bombing 14 killed, saint petersburg, russia, 3 april 2017. British counterinsurgency from malaya to iraq, journal of strategic. Counterterrorism is now a battle for hearts and minds, rather than a pure military faceoff. Since 2006, counterinsurgency has been the guiding doctrine of the u. Unlike conventional wars between nationstateswith both sides wearing uniforms and using heavy weapons, such as tanks, artillery, fixedwing aircraft, and shipsfighting nonuniformed guerrillas in an insurgency that blend back into the civilian population is often a much different and more difficult task.
Rich, grand strategy in the war against terrorism london. Hearts and minds is the story of five londoners whose lives interact. And thus, he is singularly suited to chair the panel. From the early stages of the vietnam war, american officials insisted that winning the hearts and minds yes, the acronym was wham of the south vietnamese people was the key to victory. The battle for hearts and minds discusses four aspects of soft power. He was subsequently the senior specialist in national defense at the congressional research service for twentyfour years. A divorced humanrights lawyer, a south african supply teacher, a zimbabwean cabdriver, a ukrainian teenager trafficked into prostitution, and an american pa escaping a failed relationship in her home country. Professor mockaitis coedited grand strategy and the war on terrarium london. For years after the intervention into iraq in march 2003, the united states military executed its most successful wham campaign ever during the course of a fullblown.
The first book of its kind, hearts and minds is a scathing response to. The most prominent strategy for how to counter an insurgency is to win hearts and minds. Hearts and minds is how repression had to be dressed up for consumption back in britain post1945. Buy winning hearts and minds carrutherss wellargued and welldesigned study examines how the british government dealt on the home front with counterinsurgencies in palestine 194447, malaya. The americans from the department of defense and the cia down to the lowest grunt had a colonialist attitude to the vietnamese. Strategy isnt something thats taught well in school. A history, sir lawrence freedman, one of the worlds leading authorities on war and international politics, captures the vast history of strategic thinking, in a consistently engaging and insightful account of how strategy came to pervade every aspect of our lives.
Opinion how not to win hearts and minds the new york. Winning hearts and minds if there was one matter on which all americans in south vietnam were virtually unanimous at the turn of the 196768 year, it was that pacification was still a failure. Hearts and minds in guerrilla warfare is a classic case study of the 19481960 malayan emergency which provides the broader view needed in all aspects of a counterinsurgency grand strategy. The first book of its kind, hearts and minds is a scathing response to the grand narrative of u. Selected as a financial times best book of 20 in strategy. We would do well to return to it as a study in one success story. Hearts and minds vietnam or winning hearts and minds refers to the strategy and programs. Military recruitment and the high school battlefield.
While the term hearts and minds does not accurately represent britains experience of. The american struggle for vietnams hearts and minds, a necessary book on americas pacification efforts there. Psychological operations are becoming a regular part of military strategy. The first section of the book considers failed or failing states as havens for transnational terrorist networks, and examines the most effective ways to build stable nations in unstable regions. The virulently antivietnam war documentary also is a prime example of feeblethinking vietnam veteran bashing, of what. While lbjs hearts and minds project was a military strategy, it should be distinguished from soft power or the use of diplomacy, cultural dialogue, development assistance, and propaganda to persuade others to resolve conflicts without resort to violence. If hearts and minds are different, but equally important, then to. This is unfortunate, because strategy is something that is critically relevant to. Texts about military strategy take us back into the mists of time but what it is, and what the nature of war is, remains hotly debated. Westminster attack 4 killed, london, uk, 22 march 2017. Ayers tells us, as recruiters dangle gifts and promises of future benefits before.
And almost half a century later, theyre still losing it and blaming others for doing so. Armymarine corps counterinsurgency field manual,the u. The best books on military strategy five books expert. Winning hearts and minds news newspapers books scholar jstor january 20 learn how and when to remove this template message. But some assumptions made about iraq proved faulty, and some policy decisions were controversial and created more. Popularly attributed to field marshal sir gerald templer s malayan emergency campaign against communist insurgents shortly after world war ii, the term actually dates at least as far back as the american revolution and has regularly been used to. Or consider what actually broke the back of the malayan insurgency in the early 1950s, which was not so much the heartsandminds persuasion of templer but the.
Today, winning hearts and minds has evolved in american hands from basic security to farreaching, infrastructurebuilding enterprises. Army drafted a new field manual heralding the resurrection of counterinsurgency as a primary. Duke university press battling for hearts and minds. Academic journal article phi delta kappan hearts and minds. Unlike many studies of colonial insurgency, this book examines both domestic and international aspects of the battle for hearts and minds.
Political department in his book about the northwest frontier of. In malcolm gladwells book outliers, he talks about the concept that. Counterterrorism is increasingly about winning hearts and. Hearts and minds historical counterinsurgency coin lessons to guide the war of ideas in the global war on terrorisminsurgents, historical case studies, malaya emergency 194560, vietnam war.
British counterinsurgency from malaya to iraq, journal of strategic studies 323 june 2009 p. Stern provides a riveting narration of chiles political history during this period. It is difficult for a military to win the hearts and minds of a population that they are simultaneously victimizing. Indeed, this strategy of divide and rule is the essence of british colonial policy rather than any spurious notion of winning over hearts and minds. When i first started in leadership, i worked hard, i focused on strategy, tactics, and getting results. Veterans confront the truth about us war crimes new york. Three leadership strategies for winning hearts and minds. Palm sunday attack 45 known dead, alexandria and tanta, egypt, 9. In recent years, military recruitment has failed, with rare exceptions, to meet its quotas. In response, petraeus, mattis and their staffs developed field manual 324, which formalized a coin approach that emphasized winning the hearts and minds of civilians, rather than simply defeating. Dormant as a tactic since the days of the vietnam war, in 2006 the u. Winning hearts and minds noting that, the united states and its coalition partners are attempting to win the hearts and minds of the people in iraq while providing military security and support to economic and political reform programs. Hell, most people probably couldnt tell you the difference between strategy and tactics or even know there is a difference. The first book of its kind, hearts and minds meets counterinsurgency proponents on their own playing field, retelling the history of counterinsurgency from the perspective of the populations whose hearts and minds have been fought over since the end of the world war ii.
1576 914 704 1136 1483 900 1068 1624 537 1334 416 955 1073 556 924 388 1470 249 1146 360 1378 760 1259 1289 402 107 327 299 1168 1267 730 1055 809 1256 1123 1090 1549 589 648 661 1295 964 612 486